criticalvoices

On issues that matter …

Freedoms and Responsibilities August 24, 2012

Filed under: Uncategorized — Srirekha @ 5:46 pm
Tags: , , ,

They say what happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas. But poor little royal rich kid Prince Harry is realizing otherwise what with pictures of him cavorting butt naked with a similarly undressed woman in a Vegas hotel room have made it to the front page of Britain’s most circulated tabloid, The Sun, before already going viral on the Internet.

Requests from his royal representatives to can the pictures and spare Prince Harry the embarrassment were honored by many of the other publications, but fell on deaf ears at The Sun, which cited ‘Freedom of the Press’ to print them. Editors at The Sun said their readers had a right to see the pictures. Right to see, maybe yes, but do they really want to? Or do they really need to?

Ah, ok, I’m not going to waste my breath sermonizing to a successful tabloid like the Sun on voyeuristic journalism. Its readership should shut me up, if nothing else.

In the other instance, a more serious one, the Indian government is trying to get Facebook and Twitter to ban some of its users who have been identified as being responsible for spreading hate filled messages that incited violence in Mumbai two weeks ago as also caused panic among North-East origin students in other parts of the country.

A totally legitimate move. However, it is being debated by the Indian intelligentsia, and criticized by Western media, especially the US, as a move to curb freedom of expression.

The all pervasiveness of mass media and increasing popularity of social media is making the discussion and debate on freedom of expression and freedom of the Press commonplace and clichéd with hardly any voices trying to analyze the causes and implications of such access and freedoms, on society.

Such discussion is not new since historically news media and writers in general considered their largely anti-establishment views to be sacrosanct and above reproach so long as they served the public good and hence fiercely defended their freedom of expression.

Changing times notwithstanding, such freedoms should ideally remain etched in stone. But technology, easy access and indiscriminate proliferation of mass media has given rise to new dilemmas for governments and other regulators as they struggle to keep up with mass aspirations while safeguarding their wellbeing from those misusing their freedoms.

I would say we might as well brace ourselves to a future where the very concept of privacy will die, primarily because of communications technology that will leave mass media consumers overwhelmed by that they see, hear, feel of others and also are compelled to share of themselves as they face issues of privacy, decency, criminality and crucial necessity. We may also very well be prepared to face outright curbs of certain freedoms as issues of defense and national security assume prominence.

Of course it is not enough to say that with constitutionally granted freedoms come morally imposed responsibilities. So I would say we simply bide this tide of technology-driven information tsunami by making sane choices. Like all things considered, this phase too will correct itself and fade. Until the dawn of a new era that is!

Srirekha Chakravarty

Advertisements
 

2 Responses to “Freedoms and Responsibilities”

  1. Ramgopal Says:

    The hypocrisy of the western nations and the western media is not an unknown feature. If they seek censorship it is legitimate and if India or for that matter any Third World country seeks it (even if it is in National interest), it is government intervention.. Well time will make the difference… leave it to the Grand Old Man- Time!

    • sri2907 Says:

      I totally agree. The fault mostly lies with the developing world, particularly a country like India, that has over the decades failed to set up its own unique norms and has blindly adopted media standards set by the US which is the defacto leader of the free world.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s